"She is dressed in a white robe with a blue
mantle and a crown of golden stars. Her hands are slender.
There is a brown scapular on her right arm, except when she
carried the Child Jesus in her arms. Her hair, deep
nut-brown, is parted in the center. Her face is long, with a
fine nose. Her mouth is very pretty with lips a bit thin.
She looks like a girl of eighteen. She is rather tall. There
is no voice like hers. No woman is just like her, either in
the voice or the face or anything else. " Our Lady
Manifested herself as Our Lady of Carmel."
At times the wind rustled her long hair which
reached down to her waist. The girls spoke with the Virgin
with the utmost naturalness. "We were telling her," they said,
"about our tasks, how we were going to the meadows..." and
"She smiled at the little things we told her." Our Lady showed
them how to treat her: "Like children who speak with their
mother and tell her everything...Children who rejoice to see
her when they have not seen her for a while."
More Apparitions
After this first apparition there were many more. During 1961
and 1962 Our Lady appeared several times each week. The four
girls did not always receive the apparition together.
Sometimes only one, other times two or three of them saw the
vision. Nor was it always at the same hour of the day. Our
Lady appeared many times at night and even early in the
morning, in an attitude of sacrifice and penance, at the same
hours when Our Lord is most offended by the sins of men. Even
so, the girls would arise the following morning, as early as
usual, to work in the fields, carrying bundles of grass or
wood, or tending the cattle and sheep, without showing signs
of fatigue.
The Ecstasies
When the vision appeared, the girls fell instantaneously on
their knees, striking the sharp rocks with a loud noise that
was frightening, yet they showed no signs of injury. The
expression on their faces was suddenly transformed. Their look
became extraordinarily beautiful, sweet, one of profound
mysticism. There are no words that can properly describe the
change. They were completely absorbed in their rapture,
unaware of anyone or any material thing around them except for
each other. They did no react to pricks, burns or blows. All
attempts to distract them failed. Powerful beams of strong
light were focused on them, yet their eyes did not even
flicker, blink or show any signs of discomfort. Quite the
contrary, their eyes remained wide open , expressing a look of
intense joy. However, when the girls returned to the normal
state, they immediately shielded their eyes from those bright
lights which under normal circumstances should have caused
permanent eye damage.
During these ecstasies, which lasted from a few
minutes to several hours, time did not seem to count. On many
occasions they remained immobile in off-balance, beautiful
"sculptured-like" positions, heads tilted back, eyes looking
up, kneeling on the rocks or bare-legged in the snow. At the
end of the ecstasy, they showed no signs of excitation or
nervousness, just deep, profound peace and joy.
Participation of the
Observers
Many visitors and villagers gave the girls various objects,
such as bibles, rosaries, scapulars, medals, crucifixes,
wedding rings, etc. for Our Lady to kiss. In ecstasy, the
girls raised them up to Her and She kissed them. Then guided
by Our Lady, the girls returned the items to their correct
owners, even in cases where the person had first confided the
object to someone else so the child did not know who the real
owner was. Things "kissed" by Our Lady of Carmel have been the
instruments of very special favors. Occasionally, these have
emitted a mysterious fragrance like that of roses. "Our Lady
says", Conchita wrote, "that Jesus will work miracles through
the objects kissed by her. Those who carry or wear them with
faith and confidence will suffer their purgatory here on
earth."
While in ecstasy, the girls often carried a
crucifix in their hand which Our Lady had kissed, and as She
directed, they extended it for observers to kiss, blessing
them with it at the same time. On seeing the girls approach,
many witnesses experienced such a tremendous spiritual
awakening, that it produced a very deep interior emotion in
them. They cried unashamed tears, admitting the
supernaturality of what they were seeing, hearing and feeling
within them, the very presence of the Mother of God. The
conversion of unbelievers and those of different faiths, of
souls suffering from religious indifference, the conversions
of many sinners, all of which have experienced an increase in
faith, hope, and charity.
New Phenomena
Soon after Our Lady of Carmel appeared, the ecstatic walks
began. The girls went throughout the entire village - up and
down stairways, in and out of homes, at all hours of the day
and night, avoiding obstacles without faltering, guided solely
by the vision. Frequently, they ran at great speed down the
steep mountainside, even backwards, so that it was impossible
for the astonished spectators to follow them. Their bodies did
not seem to be subject to the law of gravity, but endowed with
some sort of spiritual agility. During their high-speed
running, the objects entrusted to the girls were sometimes
lost. However, upon seeing Our Blessed Mother again, they
asked as to their whereabouts and She told them where to find
them.
The Miracle of the Host
Above the village is a steep hill on which stands a cluster of
9 pine trees. "One day," said the girls, "an angel with a
golden chalice appeared to us at "The Pines". He told us to
recite the Confiteor and then he gave us Holy Communion." This
wonderful favor happened many times during those days when the
parish priest of the neighbouring town of Cosio could not go
to Garabandal. It was possible to film some of these
Communions, using very bright light. The movements of the lips
and tongues of the girls gave the exact idea of a real
Communion. On May 2, 1962, the angel told Conchita that God
would perform a miracle so that all people would believe: they
would see the Sacred Host on her tongue at the moment of
Communion and that she should make this known fifteen days in
advance. On July 18, 1962, the town was crowded with visitors.
At midnight Conchita, who had remained in her home continually
surrounded by visitors, entered into ecstasy and went out into
the street. At a short distance from her house she fell down
on her knees in the midst of the crowd. Lanterns were focused
on her. She put out her tongue upon which nothing was resting,
as everyone could see. In a few moments, a white host appeared
on her tongue and remained there for a few minutes. A
businessman from Barcelona, Don Alejandro Damians, standing
less than three feet from the girl, secured some very good
moving pictures. In the film there appeared 79 pictures of the
extraordinary scene. This same witness wrote a report which he
submitted to the Bishop of Santander, together with a copy of
the film. The number of witnesses on this occasion was very
large: there were people from different cultures and social
classes. Don Benjamin Gomez, a farmer from Potes, wrote:
"I was standing at less than an arm's length
from the girl. I saw very well that her tongue was
completely clean of everything. The girl did not move.
Suddenly there appeared on it the Sacred Host. It was white,
shining and resplendent. It reminded one of the snow when
the sun strikes it with its brilliant rays. The girl's face
was beautifully transformed into heavenly ecstasy. Her face
was angelic I can certify that she was there motionless,
moving neither hands nor tongue. In this motionless position
she received the Sacred Host. We had enough time to
contemplate this marvellous phenomenon without any undue
haste, and we were many who saw it. I was an unbeliever
until that day. I am not such a Catholic as to be subject to
any hallucination or imagination. I had not concerned myself
about God until then except to offend Him. I went to
confession in April but previous to that time I had not gone
to confession for twenty-three years."
The miracle of the host is a true confirmation of
the apparitions of Our Blessed Mother in Garabandal and of the
reality of her message. But a still greater miracle has been
promised.
A Greater Miracle to
Come
Conchita has clearly said that Our Lady has promised a greater
miracle in Garabandal so that all may believe the apparitions
and be obedient to the message. "As the punishment which we
deserve for the sins of the world is great, the miracle must
also be a great one, for the world needs it." It will occur on
a Thursday on the feast day of a saint devoted to the
Eucharist, at 8:30 in the evening, and will last for about one
quarter of an hour. It will also coincide with a great event
in the Church. The sick who come to Garabandal on that day
will be cured, unbelievers will be converted.
There will remain a permanent sign a
"The Pines" as a proof of Our Lady's tremendous love for all
her children.
"The sign that will remain," says Conchita, "will
be able to be seen, photographed and televised but it will not
be able to be touched. It will appear clearly that it is
something not of this world, but of God."
Conchita has been granted permission by Our Lady
to announce the date of the miracle eight days in advance.
With the present means of communication and travel, eight days
are sufficient for people around the world to gather. The day
of The miracle may be the last opportunity
given us by God and may be also Our Lady's last effort to save
the world from the punishment already threatened.
Some time ago Conchita wrote, "The Blessed Virgin
will not allow me to reveal the nature of The miracle although
I already know it. Neither can I reveal the date of it, which
I know, until eight days before it is to happen." Before
The miracle takes place Our Lady has said
that all mankind will receive a warning from heaven.
The Warning
Conchita wrote: "The warning comes directly from God and will
be visible to the whole world and from any place where anyone
many happen to be. It will be like the revelation of our sins
and it will be seen and felt by everyone, believer and
unbeliever alike irrespective of whatever religion he may
belong to. It will be seen and felt in all parts of the world
and by every person."
It will happen in the sky, no one can prevent it
form happening. We will even prefer to be dead rather than to
pass through this Warning It will not kill
us. It will be a "correction" of our conscience. It will cause
great fear and will make us reflect within ourselves on the
consequences of our own personal sins. It will be like a
warning of the punishment to come. In this way the world will
be offered a means of purification to prepare itself for the
extraordinary grace of the Great Miracle.
Jacinta was told by Our Blessed Mother "that the
warning would come when conditions were at their worst." The
date was not revealed to the visionaries, however Mari-Loli
does know the year; and she said that The Miracle
will happen within one year after The Warning.
The Punishment
If we do not pay attention to the message, the punishment
announced by Our Lady will be visited on the whole world after
The miracle. During one of their ecstasies
the girls were heard praying for the innocent children but,
nevertheless, they shed tears at the same time. Since the day
they learned about the punishment they have developed a great
spirit of sacrifice. They pray very much for sinners and for
priests. They often say that if priests are not what they
should be many souls will be lost.
Conchita has written: "I cannot reveal what kind
of punishment it is except that it will be a result of the
direct intervention of God, which makes it more terrible and
fearful than anything we can imagine. It will be less painful
for innocent babies to die a natural death than for those
babies to die because of the punishment. All Catholics should
go to confession before the punishment and the others should
repent of their sins. When I saw IT (the punishment), I felt a
great fear even though at the same time I was seeing Our
Blessed Mother. The punishment, if it comes, will come after
the miracle"
When Our Lady spoke to the girls of the
punishment, her face assumed a look of great sadness. The
girls revealed: "We have never seen her look so serious. When
she said the words 'The cup is already filling', she spoke in
a very low voice."
A New Message
On January 1, 1965, Conchita had an apparition of Our Lady who
told her that on June 18, the fourth anniversary of the
apparitions, she would be given another message. Thus, six
months before the actual date Conchita revealed this promise
of Our Lady.
On June 18 more than two thousand people gathered
in Garabandal - French, Germans, English, Italians, Americans
and Polish were among the people who joined the groups from
different parts of Spain. The Spanish were in the minority,
perhaps due to the fact the apparitions had received
practically no publicity. The French constituted the largest
group. There were journalists, TV cameras from the Italian TV
network, and cameramen from NO-DO (the Spanish official
documentary news program). Leaving her house at 11:30 p.m.
Conchita walked to the road leading to the Pines to the place
called the Cuadro. There she was rapt in ecstasy which lasted
sixteen minutes. St. Michael appeared to her and delivered the
message from Our Lady, which was made public the next morning.
It reads:
Message which Our Lady has given to the world
through the intercession of St. Michael the Archangel. The
angel said, "Since my message of October 18 has not been
made known to the world and has not been fulfilled, I tell
you that this is my last message. Previously, the cup was
being filled. Now it is overflowing. Many Cardinals, many
Bishops and many Priests are on the road to perdition and
with them they are bringing many souls. The Holy Eucharist
is being given less importance (honour). We must avoid God's
anger with us by our efforts at amendment. If we beg pardon
with sincerity of soul, He will forgive us. I, your Mother,
through the intercession of St. Michael the Archangel, want
to tell you to amend your lives. You are already receiving
one of the last warnings. I love you very much and do not
want your condemnation. Ask sincerely and we will give to
you. You should make more sacrifices. Think of the Passion
of Jesus."
From this message one can clearly sense Our
Lady's disappointment at the scant attention paid to her
message of October 18, 1961. The Blessed Mother shows her
motherly concern for priests and the need to place the Holy
Eucharist where it belongs - at the center of the mysteries of
our Faith. To urge us to sacrifice, she recommends meditation
on the Passion of Our Lord.
Our Blessed mother has told us this is her last
message. Because of this she wants all her children to listen
to her plea before The warning and
The miracle. For the reason that she wishes
it, we should propagate this urgent message as widely as
possible.
Father Luis Marie
Andreu
The only other person to see Our Blessed Mother at Garabandal
was a 38-year old Spanish Jesuit Priest, Father Luis Marie
Andreu. On August 8, 1961, Father Luis was Among the
spectators at The Pines when suddenly he
became an integral part of the Garabandal drama. He was heard
to say, Miracle! Miracle!" Not only did he see The Virgin
Mary, but he was shown the forthcoming Great
Miracle. The children in ecstasy understood Our Lady to
say to him: "You will soon be with me." Although, he had never
had any history of serious illness, he died that same night of
complete joy. His final words were:
"Oh! What a sweet and lovely mother we have in
heaven...how happy I am... what a favour The Blessed Virgin
has bestowed on me. How fortunate we are to have a mother
like her in heaven!. There is no reason to fear the
supernatural life. The girls have given us an example of how
we must act with the Blessed Virgin. There is no doubt, in
my mind that the things involving the girls are true. Why
should the Blessed Virgin have chosen us? This is the
happiest day of my life."
With those words, Father bowed his head and died.
Our Lady has said, "that on the day AFTER the
Miracle his body will be found to be incorrupt."
Our Blessed Mother showed special attention and
concern for all priests, repeatedly asking that they come to
Garabandal. She gave the girls the ability to recognize them
even when they came dressed as laymen, revealing the state of
their souls. She taught the children that priests were more
important even than angels because by means of their
ordination they have the power to change bread and wine into
the Body and Blood of Christ during the Holy Sacrifice of the
Mass.
The Last
Apparition
On Saturday, November 13, 1965 Conchita had her last
apparition of Our Lady in Garabandal. She gives the details in
a letter of which the following is a literal translation:
"One day in church Our Lady told me in a
locution that I would see her on Saturday, November 13, at
the pines; it would be a special apparition to kiss the
religious objects so that I could give them away afterwards.
I was anxious for this day to arrive so that I could see
again the Blessed Virgin and the Child Jesus who have
implanted in my life the seed of God's happiness.
It was raining but it did not matter to me. I
went up to the Pines carrying with me the many rosaries
which people have given to me to distribute them... As I was
going up I was talking to myself, being sorry for my
defects, desiring not to fall into them again, for it gave
me much worry to appear before the Mother of God without
wiping them out.
When I arrived at the pines, I began to take
the rosaries out and heard a sweet voice, that of the
Virgin, which you always distinguish among others, calling
me by my name. I answered her 'what?' At that very moment I
saw Her with the Child in her arms. She was dressed as usual
and smiling. I told Her, 'I have come to bring you the
rosaries so that you can kiss them.' She said to me, 'I can
see it.' I had been chewing gum, but as I was seeing Her I
did not chew it; I placed the gum on a tooth. She must have
noticed for She said, 'Conchita why don't you get rid of the
chewing gum and offer it up as a sacrifice for the glory of
my Son?' I, a bit ashamed of myself, took it out and threw
it on the ground. She said afterwards, 'Do you remember what
I told you on your saint's day - that you would suffer much
on earth?... Now I repeat it to you. Have confidence in Us.
Then I added, 'How unworthy I am, O Mother of us, of so many
graces received through you, and now you have come to me to
help me carry the little cross I have." She said, 'Conchita,
I am not coming only for you but I am coming for all my
children, with a desire to get them closer to Our Hearts.'
She asked for the things I was carrying. 'Give them to me so
that I can kiss all you are carrying with you.' And I gave
her everything. I was bringing with me also a small crucifix
which I gave her to kiss. She kissed it and said , 'Put it
in the hands of the Child Jesus.' And I did that and He said
nothing. I said 'This cross I intend to take with me when I
go to the convent.' But he did not reply. After kissing
everything She commented, 'My son, through this kiss, will
work wonders. Distribute them to the others..." Of course I
will do it.
After all this she requested that I tell her
all the petitions for others which I had received. She said,
'Conchita, tell me, tell me things about my children. I have
all of them under my cloak.' And I commented, 'It is too
small and there is no room for all of us.' She smiled at
this.
'Do You know, Conchita, why I did not come
personally on June 18 to give you the message for the world?
Because it pained me to say it myself, but I have to say it
to you for your own good and, if you fulfil it, for God's
glory. I love you very much and I desire your salvation; to
gather you all around God the Father, the Son and the Holy
Spirit. Conchita, won't you respond to this?' I said, 'If I
could be always seeing you, yes; but otherwise I can't
because I am very bad...' 'You do all you can,' Our Lady
added, 'and We will help you, as well as my daughters Loli,
Jacinta and Maricruz...'
She did not stay long with me. She also said,
'This will be the last time you see me here, but I will
always be with all my children.' Afterwards she added, 'Conchita,
why don't you go often to visit my Son in the Most Blessed
Sacrament? Why do you let yourself be carried away by
laziness and not go to visit Him Who is waiting for you day
an night?'
As I have written above, it was raining hard.
Our Lady and the Child did not get wet. I was not aware it
was raining while seeing them, but when I stopped seeing
them I was soaked. I also told her, 'O how happy I am when I
see you. Why don't you take me with you right now?' She
answered, 'Remember what I told you on your saint's day.
When you go before God you must show Him your hands filled
with good works done by you for your brothers and for the
glory of God; now your hands are empty.'
That's all, I spent a happy moment with my
mother from heaven, my best friend, and with the Child
Jesus. I have stopped seeing them but not feeling them
close. Again they have sown in my soul great peace, joy and
a desire to conquer my defects so that I will be able to
love, with all my strength, the hearts of Jesus and Mary who
love us so much..."
Conchita ends with this: "The Blessed Virgin
Mary told me before that Jesus does not want to send the
punishment in order to distress us but in order to help us
and reproach us because we pay no attention to Him. And the
warning will be sent in order to purify us for the miracle
in which he will show us His great love, and in order that
we may fulfil the message."
With this apparition of Our Lady, the cycle of
apparitions in Garabandal closed. It will be definitely
confirmed on a Thursday at 8:30 p.m. when The
miracle takes place. This will mark the beginning of a new
era in the history of the salvation of mankind.
chastisement. imminent an for ourselves disposing
are we that and serious extremely is situation world the fact
of aware be should We humanity. deaf blind a on fall to about
which Justice Divine Arm staying responsibility tremendous in
her with work us one each pleading mother, as love great
showing Mother, Blessed Our
Position of the Church
As always, the Church has acted with great
prudence toward the apparitions. It took thirteen years for
the Church to give the official approval to the Fatima
apparitions even after seventy thousand people witnessed the
miracle of the sun.
A special emissary from Holy Office was sent to
Garabandal to investigate the witnesses of the apparitions. By
special request of the Pro-Secretary of the same Congregation
of the Faith, Cardinal Ottaviani, Conchita went to Rome in
1966 accompanied by her mother and a priest. She met with
Cardinal Ottaviani and other officials of the Vatican. With
Cardinal Marella she was received in a private audience by
Pope Paul VI.
For obvious reasons, nothing more can be said
regarding this intervention of Rome. However it is necessary
to confirm this visit of Conchita to the Holy Office in order
to refute rumours that no private audience with His Holiness
had been granted to Conchita. He said to her "Conchita I bless
you and with me the whole Church blesses you."
The Final and decisive Judgement of these events
belongs exclusively to the Supreme Magisterium of the Church.
St. Michael's Garabandal Centre accepts any decision fully,
from the moment it shall be pronounced.
Questions and Answer
Question:
Regarding the Garabandal major prophecies can you clarify when
and what is going to happen in relation to the year 2000 that
everyone is talking about?
Answer:
First of all there were many prophecies foretold at
Garabandal. Several have already happened. However, I suggest
that you read carefully the Garabandal prophecies listed here
on the official web site:
The
Warning,
The
Miracle, and the
Punishment. However, I want to point out two important
factors:
1)The Miracle must follow the warning within 12
months, but not necessarily within the same calendar year.
This prophecy was told to us by Mari-Loli who Knows the year
of The World Wide Warning. She was not told
by Our Blessed Mother to announce it or not to announce it. It
is not known whether she will eventually tell it or not. Up to
now she does not feel she should. She does not know how much
time will elapse between the two, only that there could be as
much as a 12-month span. She reconfirmed this once again in
December 1996. Remember: The Warning first
and then The Miracle. Furthermore, we also
know that the miracle will happen in the month of April. (The
Vigil Jan-April 1988 explains why we no longer consider
March and May to be valid.) Conchita knows the exact date and
will announce it eight days in advance and the means of
communicating the date to the world will (according to what
Conchita told me in 1969) be a miracle in itself. She also
told me that: "The World Wide Warning must happen Before the
announcement of the miracle."
2)When it comes to Garabandal, as far as the year
2000 goes, we must be very careful not to not start putting
dates and events together to make them fit into what we think
or what others have claimed. However, Conchita did say that an
important, happy event of the Church will coincide with the
day of the miracle. It will be something that has never before
happened during her lifetime. It will not be the result of the
miracle but rather a coincidence. None of the four visionaries
have ever told to me, or to my knowledge anyone else, that the
major prophecies must be completed by the year 2000. For sure,
we certainly need to prepare ourselves prayerfully through Our
Blessed Mother, as our Holy Father, Pope John Paul II has
indicated. He has been telling us that 1997 opens the
preparatory phase of the Great Jubilee of the year 2000, which
holds a very special meaning for all mankind in relationship
to the most blessed Trinity.
Question:
Lately, I have heard there is a letter of disapproval as of
October of 1996 regarding the Garabandal apparitions issued by
Bishop Jose Villaplano, the present Bishop from the Santander
Diocese. Is this true? Please name the source of whatever
answer you give.
Answer:
Let's get one thing clear once and for all. The Garabandal
apparitions have NEVER BEEN CONDEMNED NOR ARE THEY NOW
DISAPPROVED. That information has been circulated by an
anonymous person or persons to give the impression that
Garabandal as of October has been "disapproved." "laid to
rest" and other such deceiving descriptive words (The English
version of the letter you are referring to, that I have seen
has a few very serious translation errors which in those cases
actually changes the meaning.) We do not now and never will
deal with accusations by those who refuse to acknowledge who
they are. Unfortunately so-called "reliable" sources magnify
this false attitude by copying and even publishing it without
verification. The truth of the matter is that the letter in
question is not, I repeat IT IS NOT an official or even a
public declaration of anything new regarding Garabandal. The
apparitions have been and continue to be classified as
"natural" not "supernatural." Exactly what does this mean? It
means that in no way can the church call it "supernatural"
until the prophesied events take place, that is:
The Warning, The Miracle, and The perpetual sign. These
three supernatural events are unchangeable. Only the fourth
major prophecy which is the chastisement is conditional. It
depends on whether or not we fulfil the messages of Garabandal
given to us by Our Blessed Mother. So because it was the
Bishop's own choice not to go public with what we have known
right along, (in his letter) out of respect for him and his
decision, neither will we go public with it. What the Bishop
does say is that: "I don't find it necessary to have a new
public declaration..., I accept the decision of my
predecessors..." The mimeographed form letter is at least two
years old and given only to those how inquire about the
position of the church. I first saw it about a year ago, and
did not consider it to be anything new or even worth
mentioning. No new prohibitions were imposed. Everyone and
anyone is free to go to Garabandal, live the messages and make
them known. The previous Bishop, Bishop Juan Antonio del Val
Gallo, (the only Bishop who actually witnessed the girls in
ecstasy while he was still a young priest) removed all the
restrictions and prohibitions during the 1980's except one
which we reported in The Vigil years ago. Any
priest who wishes to offer Holy Mass, of course, must get
permission from the local pastor. This is no different from
any other Catholic church anywhere else in the world. The
visions or any other visions not approved by the church are
not to be preached in the village church. Furthermore, while
there, Holy Mass may not be offered outside the village church
of San Sebastian. (Bishop Del Val may be seen in:
Garabandal the Eyewitnesses the only
video in the world where he appears during an exclusive
interview and reaffirms that the Garabandal Messages are
theologically correct. In August 1996 Jacinta visited with
Bishop Villaplano, with her family. She asked the Bishop for
his permission to accept an invitation to attend a Marian
Conference in Mexico. At first he seemed reluctant but then
gave her his approval. She was allowed to attend and permit
the audience to venerate her crucifix kissed by Our Blessed
Mother at Garabandal. She also accepted an invitation to
Canada, in November 1996.
Jesus has told us at Garabandal: "Do not be
concerned whether they believe you or not, I will do all!!!"
What Science says about Garabandal
What Does Science Say About Garabandal?
Many Eminent doctors have studied the events and have visited
the persons involved at Garabandal. No one has so far found
any satisfactory scientific explanation for these events. All
agree that what occurred at Garabandal is something humanly
unexplainable and something which merits attention and
respect. One thing is clear - we find ourselves before certain
facts for which science can find no explanation.
After years of Observation, a child specialist
has certified that the girls have always been completely
normal and that the ecstasies do not fall under any known
physiological phenomena. Dr. Ricardo Puncernau, a well known
Barcelona neuropschiatrist states: "In the presence of these
facts it is difficult for the doctor to give a merely natural
explanation... From a strictly scientific point of view one
cannot deny, at least thus far, the possibility of a
supernatural cause in all these phenomena." Dr. Gasca Ruiz and
Dr. Ortis Gonzalez , who have also studied these phenomena
state, "To keep silence would be true scientific cowardice on
our part. We do not find any convincing scientific explanation
capable of explaining such phenomena."